Where every treat is a happy treat 

ORDER NOW

Welcome to Happy Oven Bake Shop!

We PROMISE—The treats taste as good as they look!

We are two friends baking delicious treats in the greater Buffalo, NY area. As of right now, we are only selling locally and are not shipping items. All items are available for pickup, in Amherst or Clarence Center, or for delivery, for an additional fee. We hope you can treat yourself or loved ones to something that makes your heart and taste buds happy!

Now baking 100% artificial dye-free cookies! Ask us more about it!

About Us
Assorted colorful birthday cookies on pink tray featuring a pineapple with sunglasses, a watermelon with sunglasses, a flamingo, a beach ball, a pineapple with sunglasses, and decorated cookies with birthday messages, all on a pink glittery surface with green fabric in the background.

Custom Sugar Cookies

We work with you to design the perfect cookies that you are envisioning!

Learn more
Table with ready to decorate sugar cookies, piping practice sheet, small bowls of candy, icing piping bags, and scissors for Valentine's Day cookie decorating.

Classes

We offer sugar cookie decorating classes and sourdough classes throughout the year!

Learn more

Order Process

1. We brainstorm

You don't pay until you approve! Once you submit an order inquiry, we work together to come up with the perfect set designed to complement your event and needs.

2. You approve and pay

When you're happy with the concept and the price, we send you an invoice - once that's paid, you're on the books! We'll reach out to you around the time of your pick-up to remind you about your order.

3. You pickup

Once your order is boxed and ready, you swing by Amherst or Clarence Center (whichever was agreed upon in your order inquiry) to grab your custom cookies. Instructions for freshness are included (and we will throw in a "car cookie" for you to eat on your drive home).

Order Now

FAQs

  • We are located in the Northtowns. We have pickup locations in Amherst and Clarence Center.

  • It depends what you are looking for! We have three tiers that start at $50 for a basic set and increase from there. We will discuss pricing with you before you receive and invoice so there are no surprises!

  • If we are not booked out already, we’ll need about 2 weeks to source the cookie cutters, ingredients, and designs for your order. Under a week before you need your cookies? Ask us still! We may be able to take your order, but there will be a fast track fee.

  • We are not an allergy-friendly nor gluten-free bakery. Our ingredients include eggs, butter, and flour and are baked in a cottage kitchen that contains nuts.

  • Discovering that some kids (and adults) are allergic or sensitive to artificial or synthetic dye, made us decide to change our ingredients. Our cookies are made with ZERO artificial dye. While some colors may look different than we are used to in our bright and over saturated world, we promise we can produce stunning colors for your cookies with no synthetic dyes.

  • Head to our Classes page to see when our next cookie and sourdough classes are scheduled. We try to host cookie classes once a month and sourdough classes 3-4 times a year.

Straight from the mouths of our happy customers

  • "If you haven't yet, you have to try the delicious treats from Happy Oven Bake Shop! Everything I have tasted from them has been delicious, especially their custom sugar cookies! To top it off, the owners/bakers are wonderful to deal with and take so much pride in their products! I highly recommend them!" -Shannon C.

  • "These sugar cookies look amazing and taste even better. They are creative and were the perfect finishing touch for our child’s birthday party." -Michael A.

  • "I got cookies for my SIL’s wedding rehearsal and they did NOT disappoint! I wish I could add pictures but they don’t do them justice, they were beautiful and just what I asked for! All the details down to their wedding colors, and last name in the champagne bottle with sparkles! They also tasted phenomenal which is important too! I’d highly recommend them, and will be coming back for future events!! Thank you so much again!" -Kaylee R.

  • "The sugar cookies from Happy Oven Bake Shop are not just cute and very well done, but they taste really good too! The icing and cookie are both delicious!" -Charlene S.

  • I took this class recently after watching and saving tons of sourdough videos for several months. It was nice to find someone local who could walk me through the steps and be able to have a hands on experience! We were given step by step instructions to take home and the class itself allowed for tons of interaction and questions as you go. I went home with the confidence to get started right away and have also been able to ask questions even after the class as well for a little extra support!  -Jessica J.

Sweeten Your Inbox!

Sign up with your email address to receive delicious news and updates.